Neighborhood Comparison

Valencia vs Newhall: Modern Master-Planned vs Historic Character

Valencia and Newhall represent two distinct approaches to Santa Clarita living. Valencia is a modern master-planned community known for its walkability, shopping, and resort-style amenities. Newhall is Santa Clarita's historic downtown, offering character-filled homes, arts and culture, and a more traditional neighborhood feel. Both offer excellent value, but appeal to very different buyer preferences.

Valencia
A Master-Planned Community with Modern Amenities

Price Range

$650K - $1.5M

Median: $850K

Top School Rating

9/10

Population

35,000

Newhall
Historic Charm Meets Modern Living

Price Range

$550K - $0.9M

Median: $700K

Top School Rating

8/10

Population

28,000

Key Differences

Side-by-side comparison of the most important factors when choosing between these neighborhoods

Price Range

Valencia

Single-family homes $650K-$1.5M, median $850K

Newhall

Single-family homes $550K-$950K, median $700K

Home Style

Valencia

Modern tract homes (1980s-2020s), planned neighborhoods

Newhall

Mix of historic homes (1920s-1960s) and newer construction

Community Vibe

Valencia

Suburban, family-oriented, master-planned amenities

Newhall

Historic downtown, arts district, walkable Main Street

Lot Sizes

Valencia

Typically smaller lots (5,000-8,000 sq ft), HOA communities

Newhall

Larger lots (8,000-15,000+ sq ft), many non-HOA properties

Schools

Valencia

Modern school facilities with high ratings (8-10/10)

Newhall

Mix of historic and modern schools (7-9/10 ratings)

Lifestyle

Valencia

Shopping malls, theme parks, organized recreation

Newhall

Arts venues, breweries, farmers market, community events

Which Neighborhood Is Right For You?

Valencia Is Best For:
  • Families seeking modern homes with turnkey condition
  • Buyers who want resort-style amenities and HOA services
  • Those who prioritize walkability to shopping and dining
  • Families with school-age children seeking top-rated schools
  • First-time buyers wanting move-in ready properties
Newhall Is Best For:
  • Buyers seeking character homes with unique architecture
  • Those who prefer larger lots and more privacy
  • Buyers looking for better value per square foot
  • Families who appreciate arts, culture, and downtown lifestyle
  • Investors and those willing to renovate for equity

Ready to Find Your Perfect Home?

Get personalized guidance on Valencia, Newhall, and all Santa Clarita neighborhoods.

More Neighborhood Comparisons

Valencia vs Stevenson Ranch
Compare upscale master-planned communities
Valencia vs Newhall
Modern amenities vs historic character
Saugus vs Canyon Country
Affordable family-friendly options